Zack Dunlap, Considered ‘Brain Dead’ in 2007, Is a Living Witness to the Spuriousness of ‘Brain Death’

LifeSiteNews has published a fascinating article by Doyen Nguyen, M.D., S.T.D. — a Catholic moral theologian/bioethicist who is also a physician — on how the case of Zach Dunlap exposes the medical and ethical incoherence of so-called “brain death.”

This is a perfect example of what Dr. Paul A. Byrne discussed with me recently, in Reconquest Episode 453: “The Lie(s) Behind ‘Brain Death.’” It is also one more reason, among many, why you must not sign up to be an organ donor.

Here is an AI-produced summary of Dr. Nguyen’s article: ¹

• Zack Dunlap’s Case: Zack Dunlap, a 21-year-old from Oklahoma, was declared brain dead after an ATV accident in 2007. Doctors prepared to harvest his organs for donation.
• Family’s Intervention: Before organ harvesting, Zack’s family noticed subtle signs of life, such as movement and responses to stimuli, prompting them to halt the procedure.
• Recovery: Despite being declared brain dead, Zack eventually regained consciousness and made a significant recovery, challenging the validity of his initial diagnosis.
• Criticism of Brain Death Criteria: The case raises questions about the reliability of brain death diagnoses, as Zack’s recovery suggests that such determinations can be premature or inaccurate.
• Ethical Concerns: The incident underscores ethical dilemmas in organ donation and the potential for misdiagnosing patients who may still have a chance of recovery.
• Medical and Legal Implications: Zack’s story highlights the need for stricter criteria and better diagnostic tools to ensure that people who are alive are not labeled dead so that their organs can be harvested.

This summary cuts out all of the technical language of Dr. Nguyen’s article, which readers should consult for further information, and for links to still more.

What if Zach’s family member, who was a nurse, had not noticed that Zach was still alive? He was slated to have his organs removed. How many living people’s organs are harvested in our hospitals? Do not let this happen to you or your loved ones: Click here to request a ‘Life Guardian’ Booklet and Medical Card THAT CAN SAVE YOUR LIFE OR THE LIVE OF SOMEONE YOU LOVE.

---