When the Shepherd Strays: The New Mass, St. Robert Bellarmine, and the Possibility of a Heretical Pope

A Review and Discussion of Two Timely Issues by Arnaldo da Silveira

Recently, a friend recommended this most interesting and timely book. Although the first portion was originally written in 1970, shortly after the Novus Ordo Mass was introduced, the author continued to revise and update it until shortly before his death in 2018, answering many questions that have arisen about the nature of the New Mass, the authority of its authors, the possibility of error or heresy, etc. It can be a rather technical book, but the author is carefully determining the exact status of the New Mass, as well as meticulously investigating the possibility of a pope that could be in heresy, and if he is, what can be done about it. The author is decidedly not a sedevacantist, but meticulously lays out the various opinions should the reality of a heretical pope arise.

The first part of the book includes a detailed, at times line-by-line, analysis of the Novus Ordo Mass, comparing it with the Traditional Latin Mass, showing the radical differences between the two. This part of the book was begun in 1969, when the first version of the Novus Ordo was released. Following a great outcry from clergy, religious, and the faithful, revisions were made to the first edition and a new one was released in 1970. The author considers both versions of the New Mass, both of which he finds wanting.

Da Silveira also addresses the issue of authority and the Novus Ordo. At the time I first encountered the problem of the New Mass, friends in various parts of the United States went to their local diocesan offices and were informed that the “Old Mass” had been abrogated, meaning it was formally forbidden by the highest authority in the Church. Those of us who saw through this error, that it was actually a misuse of authority, avoided the Novus Ordo and made many sacrifices in order to attend the Traditional Latin Mass.

The author gives us the final answer concerning the level of authority used to promulgate the new rite. It comes from Pope Paul VI himself: “the rite and the respective rubrics are not by themselves a dogmatic definition; they are susceptible of theological qualification of varying value, according to the liturgical context to which they refer….”1 Thus, those who asserted that the Old Mass was abrogated and it was required for all Catholics to suffer with the New Mass were mistaken after all.

Finally, the author provides a conclusion, in which he offers his personal scholarly opinion on whether Catholics should attend the New Mass. Based on his many years of careful research, he admonishes Faithful Catholics: don’t attend the Novus Ordo Mass.2

Since da Silveira wrote his original analysis, many books written by most competent authors from Michael Davies to Peter Kwasniewski have examined the New Mass as well. All serious attempts at such analysis have concluded something similar: While it is certainly not per se invalid, the new rite has many significant problems, and it is best to avoid the Novus Ordo Mass if possible.

Part Two of the book deals with the possibility of a heretical pope, a topic that is as timely as ever, given some of the contents of papal statements over the last decade, statements which, understood in their most obvious sense, are at variance with what we know to be in the sacred Deposit of the Faith.

Da Silveira spent more than four decades researching the opinions of various orthodox theologians who have examined this problem, including Suarez, Cajetan, and Bellarmine, actually going back to the early days of the Church, to the days of Honorius I. On page 170, the author provides a very nice chart which lays out clearly five different opinions of how to deal with a heretical pope as they are described by Saint Robert Bellarmine. It is one thing to have a heretical pope, but what to do about it requires many careful distinctions. After carefully defining a theological opinion — “Assent to a probable proposition that does not certainly exclude its contradictory as untrue”3 — the author looks at each of them in great detail.

Though there are some nuances, the five major opinions given by Saint Robert Bellarmine — the “Father of Ecclesiology” — are:

  1. The pope cannot be a heretic;
  2. Falling into heresy, even merely internal heresy, the pope loses the papacy ipso facto;
  3. Even though he falls into heresy, the pope does not lose his office;
  4. The heretical pope is not deposed ipso facto. Rather, the Church must declare him deposed;
  5. The heretical pope is deposed ipso facto when his heresy becomes manifest.

The author examines each one of these opinions in turn. The first, that a pope cannot be a heretic, is shown to be unacceptable when da Silveira looks at history. He gives several examples including that of Honorious I, who did not defend the Church against the monothelites, and whose body was exhumed from the grave and condemned by his successor. History also gives us Pope John XXII, who held the heresy that after death, the souls who are saved do not enjoy the beatific vision until the resurrection of the body. He abjured this heresy shortly before his death. It is clear that the man who holds the office of the papacy can fall into heresy.

The second opinion — if a pope falls into mere internal heresy, he loses the papacy ipso facto — is also set aside by the author. “The arguments opposed to this second opinion are mainly grounded on the visible character of the Church, because of which it is impossible to declare the loss of jurisdiction for reasons unknowable and unverifiable by the faithful.”4 In the end, da Silveira explains that, today, the idea has been completely abandoned by theologians.

The third opinion — that even if the pope falls into notorious heresy, he never loses the papacy — is held by only one of the 136 ancient and modern theologians the author cites as having expressed an opinion on the matter. That lone theologian, French canonist Bouix, holds that the evil done by a heretical pope is not as bad as the evil done by deposing him or by claiming he loses the papacy ipso facto. Instead, Bouix holds that, when there is doubt, one should continue to respect the authority of the pope in all things that are not opposed to the principles of the Faith.5 While da Silveira agrees with this last statement, his conclusion is that this opinion “does not harmonize with numerous texts of Sacred Scripture (and 135 other theologians), and does not seem to give due importance to the extreme evil a heretical pope could do to the church….”6 In addition, the opinion does not provide a remedy for such a situation.

The fourth opinion is this: the heretical pope only loses the papacy with an act declaratory of his heresy. He does not lose the papacy ipso facto because of his heresy, but because there is a formal declaration that he is a heretic. Francisco Suarez maintains when the man in the office is a heretic, “…he is not a member of the Church as far as the substance and form which constitute the members of the Church. However, he is the head as far as the office and action.”7 However, he adds, “If he is a heretic and incorrigible, the pope ceases to be pope as soon as a declared sentence of his crime is pronounced against him by the legitimate Church jurisdiction.”8

The author agrees with Saint Robert Bellarmine when he refutes this opinion because of the danger of engaging in another heresy, that of Conciliarism, which claims that the pope is not the highest authority in the Church, but rather, that a Council holds this authority over him. (This error can lead directly to Gallicanism, which says that the pope does not have jurisdiction over states and governments, or even that they, in fact, have jurisdiction over him.) “What divisions could not arise if some cardinals and bishops declared the pope a heretic while others supported him!”9

It’s good to keep in mind that these various opinions were debated over many years by very famous and learned theologians such as Cajetan, Suarez, Saint Alphonsus de Liguori, and Saint Robert Bellarmine, among many others. They had different views and never came to any firm agreement, thus it is difficult for anyone to have certitude when the merely theoretical becomes scandalously existential. The author of this book was still living when Pope Francis was reigning, making this debate something more than an academic exercise. With this reality in mind, the author continues with a very thorough discussion of Bellarmine’s fifth option, making very careful distinctions in order to avoid falling into error, while providing a means for the Church to rectify the situation. After all, it is one thing to speculate on the possibility of a heretical pope, but it is another thing entirely to determine how to deal with the real situation. Da Silveira warns us that one of the biggest dangers for those living under the rule of a heretical pope is to latch onto one or another of these opinions and run with it without considering the entire question. That’s how sedevacantists (those who hold that the man who currently holds the papacy is not the pope) get themselves into trouble, and he wants to avoid that trap.

The fifth opinion: falling into manifest heresy, the pope loses the papacy ipso facto.10 The author quotes Bellarmine himself: “Now the fifth true opinion is that a pope who is a manifest heretic ceases in himself to be pope and head, just as he ceases in himself to be a Christian and member of the body of the Church; whereby he can be judged and punished by the Church.”11 He adds that a secret heretic does not lose his office. He is a sinner, and like any other sinner, he remains a member of the Church, and can repent of his sin. The author then proceeds to analyze this opinion and its many nuances at great length over several chapters.

Finally, after carefully parsing out all of the various opinions and their pitfalls, being adamant that he is not a sedevacantist, da Silveira lays out his argument for the Fifth Opinion in the following manner:

  1. It is theologically certain that nothing in Revelation asserts that the pope will never fall into heresy. Therefore, in principle, the pope may become a formal heretic.

  2. The supreme pontiff may be a heretic as a private person. And he can also be one as a public person when teaching as a pope, albeit without fulfilling conditions of infallibility.

  3. It is theologically certain that by becoming a formal heretic or being one already when elected, the pope should lose his office, since he is no longer a member of the visible Church and because there is a profound incompatibility between heresy and ecclesiastical jurisdiction.

  4. It is theologically certain that the loss of office is not automatic, nor does it take place by an act of an ecclesiastical body but ipso facto, that is, by the very fact of the full manifestation of heresy by the pope himself.

  5. The loss of office by the heretical pope, like other fundamental facts in the life of the Church, a visible and perfect society, must be clearly brought to the knowledge of the faithful.

  6. Since, as a visible society, the Church’s official acts must also be visible, the heretical pope continues in office until the full external manifestation of his heresy. In this period, he will already have lost the papacy in root while keeping it precariously and in a state of violence, an anomalous situation to be corrected as soon as possible.

  7. To combat heresy, one should bear in mind the value of prayer and penance and the notions, among others, of the quasi promulgatio of the pope’s formal heresy, the sana pars12 of Catholics, the clamor of the faithful, the texture of Catholic public opinion, leading and follower souls (planets and satellites), the sensus fidei, the passive infallibility of the faithful, the full manifestation of the pope’s heresy.

  8. A heretical pope or one suspected of heresy will be admonished twice so that he confesses the true Faith or manifests his pertinacity by responding or failing to respond. These admonitions or warnings, made by cardinals, bishops, other ecclesiastics, or even laymen, all in their sole condition of faithful Catholics, will not be official or jurisdictional acts but private acts of fraternal correction or charity.

  9. If the pope is pertinacious in heresy, his defection in the Faith, the divine right applicable to the case, and the loss of office will be announced to tota Ecclesia. This announcement will be made by ecclesiastics, in the capacity of simple faithful, or even by laymen, and not by any official body of the Church.

  10. Saint Robert Bellarmine teaches that the heretical pope loses the papacy when his heresy becomes manifest. This is to be understood as full manifestation, that is, one that imposes itself to acceptance by the sana pars of Catholics. If a block of Catholics considers the manifestation doubtful or insufficient, it is either because it is not full or the block’s members are not the true sana pars. A clash will then become inevitable, with everything depending on the sensus fidei of Catholics and the movements of grace.

  11. For as long as he is tolerated and accepted by the universal Church, the heretic will be a true pope, and, in principle, his acts are valid.

  12. The loss of the papacy, therefore will not result from a deposition by anyone but from an act of the pope himself, who, by becoming a formal and notorious heretic, will have excluded himself from the visible Church, thus tacitly resigning the papacy.

  13. The Apostolic See being vacant, an ecclesiastical body such as the College of Cardinals or the imperfect Council can legally declare the loss of office by the heretic who was pope to render the fact official and make it unequivocally known by all. The Church may then proceed to the election of a new pope.

By taking this approach, da Silveira winds his way among those who maintain that the pope can never be in heresy; avoiding the heresy of conciliarism, that, somehow, the pope and the rest of the hierarchy are equals; and the error of sedevacantism — the man who currently holds the papal office is not the pope, but is a usurper. The author also informs us that the opinion of most theologians who have studied this problem is that the faithful and the hierarchy are to resist and correct any heretical statements made by the pope, whether oral or in official papal documents.

It is of utmost importance to keep in mind that all five opinions are just that: theological opinions. Da Silveira himself is the first to remind the reader that all of this is fine and good in theory, but in practice it will not be so clear, and any actions to rectify the situation are likely to cause confusion and disruption, especially if the current pope refuses to accept the charge of heresy and refuses to resign the papacy, especially if he rallies his friends to support his claim to the papacy.

Such an action would also require enough sensus fidei, a true sense of the Faith among the faithful, which there is reason to doubt sincerely at this point in history. In addition, it would require a significant portion of the clergy to have the same sensus fidei in order even to consider accusing the pope of heresy. Practically speaking, an outcry against any heresy from either of these two groups is highly unlikely. No one, not even other cardinals or bishops, has the authority to formally denounce the pope as a heretic. They may ask questions. They may present him with his errors. They may even ask him to resign. But they simply do not have the authority to remove him from office. We must never forget that the pope is the supreme ruler of the Church.

Many of us are aware of the questions (dubia) which were submitted to Pope Francis by several cardinals in regard to the papal document, Amoris Laetitia. The pope did answer them, even though he may have done so in a way that obfuscated rather than clarified the matter. Given what was said above, a small handful of cardinals does not seem sufficient to have much of an impact on removing a heretical pope.

The bottom line of this discussion seems to be, while da Silveira presented an excellent, careful and extremely well-researched and detailed discussion of the possibility of a heretical pope, such a theoretical discussion may or may not translate into action. On the other hand, it does provide a guide to those who consider this question and may help them to avoid some of the traps that others have fallen into.

The Slaves of the Immaculate Heart of Mary at Saint Benedict Center have taken a similar approach to the one presented here. They accept as a valid pope the man whom the world recognizes as the reigning pontiff. At the same time, they are careful to reject any errors or heretical statements that may be issued from him personally or from the Vatican. In addition, they emphasize any and all good and correct things that the pope may say and always attempt to show the papacy in the best light possible, knowing full well that there is no other office on the face of the earth with greater authority, an office that was instituted by Our Lord Jesus Christ, Himself.


— Footnotes —

1. Da Silveira, Arnaldo Xavier, Two Timely Issues: The New Mass and the Possibility of a Heretical Pope, Foundation for Christian Civilization, Inc., 2022, p. 150.

2. Brother Francis provided advice to his followers which was a bit different. In order to clearly uphold the authority of the Church to establish rites and rituals, Brother said that we could accept as valid the Novus Ordo, as it was originally promulgated by Paul VI. If someone attended the New Mass and was confronted by anything which deviated significantly from this, he could, in conscience, leave, and not return in the future. That being said, the only certain means of assuring a valid Mass was to attend the Traditional Latin rite. Also, we do not condemn those Catholics who attend the Novus Ordo out of necessity or for their own personal reasons. The Slaves of the Immaculate Heart of Mary at Saint Benedict Center in Richmond, New Hampshire, attend the Traditional Latin Mass as their own proper rite, avoiding the Novus Ordo.

3. Wuellner, Bernard, S.J., Dictionary of Scholastic Philosophy, Bruce Publishing, 1956

4. Da Silveira, Ibid. p. 188

5. Da Silveira, Ibid., p. 193, footnote 786

6. Ibid., p. 195

7. Ibid., p. 199

8. Ibid., p. 200

9. Ibid., p. 199, footnote 802

10. In my many discussions with people who hold the sedevacantist position, they tended to latch onto this part of the fifth option and run with it, citing Bellarmine as their authority.

11. Da Silveira, Ibid., p. 207.

12. Meaning, “the sound [or healthy] part,” that is, those of sound mind and doctrine.